Thursday, January 26, 2012

Deciphering Evolution and Eating Part Three: Grains

As we mentioned in part two, hunter gatherers had little choice then to domesticate and mass produce grains to feed a growing population who had become too efficient at hunting and gathering. Unfortunately, domesticated grains are now our least compatible food source.

The last few years have brought forth fervent calls for humans to shun refined grains in lieu of whole grains. On paper, this may seem like an intelligent public health message. Whole wheat, for example, seems to be a powerhouse of nutrients, providing at least 100% of the RDA for many vitamins and minerals. But when compared with lean meats, seafood, fresh vegetables, and fruits, whole grains are inferior. The nutrient content of whole grains is also very misleading.

We will not discuss refined grains because simply, they have no place in our food system. The reasons are well documented.

Whole Grain Fiber
Another popular public health message is to eat copious amounts of whole grain fiber. This is misguided. You may ask, "how can I get the fiber I need without eating whole grains?"
  • Vegetables blow away grains with regard to fiber content. Fruits exceed whole grains as well, but to a lesser degree.

  • Whole grains are mostly of the insoluble variety, which does not have the cholesterol-lowering effect of soluble fiber that is present in fresh fruits and vegetables.
Phytate: the Antinutrient Problem
We would venture to say that you have not heard the term antinutrient. All whole grains contain a substance called phytate, which binds to minerals, making them unavailable for absorption in the gastrointestinal tract. What's worse is the more whole grains you eat, the greater the chance that you will be deficient in minerals. This is one of several reasons why so many vegans and vegetarians that come to see us are so unhealthy.

Vitamin D and Calcium Compromised
Overall whole grain consumption impairs vitamin D and calcium metabolism. Where calcium in grains is bound to phytate, calcium in vegetables is not. Even worse, whole grains are high in phosphorous, which further impairs calcium absorption.

Vitamin D is one, if not the, most important hormone (yes, it is a hormone) for overall health. We have documented numerous times the detrimental effect whole grains have on vitamin D levels. It is believed that two elements of whole grains create deficiency. First, whole grains interrupt the normal recycling process of vitamin D between the intestines and liver. Second, lectins, such as wheat germ agglutinin (WGA), enter the bloodstream through the gut barrier and bind to cells, blocking entry of hormones into the nucleus. Lectins are fascinating in that they act as antinutrients in plants to ward off predators from eating their leaves. Most are harmless to us, except for those in grains and legumes.

Little did our ancestors know they were growing "antinutrient super plants!"

Celiac Disease and Gluten Intolerance
We comment on this issue so often that we do not need to spend a great amount of time on it. However, we have come up with the most recent list of maladies believed to be attributed to gluten intolerance:


Acid reflux, Addison's disease, Alopecia, Anemia, Asthma, Ataxias, Attention deficit disorder, Atopic diseases, Autism, Autoimmune eye and thyroid diseases,
Canker Sores, Dementia, Dental enamel defects, Depression and anxiety, Dermatitis herpetiformis, Eating disorders, Epilepsy, Grave's disease, Hashimoto's disease, Hyperactivity, Infertility, Immune system dysfunction, Irritable bowel syndrome, Kidney inflammation, Liver disease, Migraines, Peripheral neuropathies, Psoriasis, Rheumatoid arthritis, Schizophrenia, Sjogren's syndrome, Systemic lupus, Type 1 diabetes, and Vitiligo

Celiac expert Dr. Alessio Fasano believes that up to 20 million people in the United States have gluten intolerance. If corroborated, this is a truly staggering number and would be considered a threat to public health. In our opinion, it is already is.

Grain Seeds: Insignificant in Our Ancestral Dietary Pecking Order
According to Paleo researcher Loren Cordain, when hunter-gatherers had their druthers, they chose food in this order:
  1. Large animals
  2. Medium-size animals
  3. Small animals, birds, and fish
  4. Roots and tubers
  5. Fruit
  6. Honey
  7. Nuts and seeds
  8. Grass seeds (pseudo-cereals)
As you can see, grass seeds were not consumed very often. Mostly because in the wild, plants produce seeds only for a few weeks or months out of the year. Now they are available to us all year round. Hunter-gatherers may have also known that seeds represented a plant's reproductive future. Plants protect themselves with hard shells, spikes, and antinutrients containing toxins to ward off predators. Seeds that we currently eat as alternatives to glutenous grains, such as quinoa, chia, buckwheat, and amaranth, are grain seeds that contain antinutrients. While they have minimal effects if eaten in moderation, if you consume them in amounts similar to the glutenous grains you replaced, harmful effects may occur. Repeated exposure to high amounts of antinutrients in any form can create nutrient deficiency, impair intestinal function, and create chronic inflammation.

The moral here is to be judicious in your grain and pseudo grain consumption. Start out by trying to replace one grain serving per day with a fruit or vegetable.

Just to refresh your memory.
What is considered a grain
: Wheat, Rye, Barley, Oats, Corn, Rice, Sorghum, Spelt and Millet.
What is considered a pseudo-grains: Buckwheat, Chia Seeds, Amaranth, and Quinoa.

No comments:

Post a Comment