Thursday, January 12, 2012

Deciphering Evolution and Eating Part One: Then and Now

You have heard it from us before. If we could only emulate in modern society how our hunter gatherers predecessors ate. The reason is simple. Our genes are virtually unchanged since that era. The Paleolithic or Stone Age way of eating to this day mirrors what our body craves and deserves. The only problem is that since that time, dietary trends have monumentally changed, and we are paying for it.

In addition, the extremes that humans have taken with diet (vegetarianism and veganism especially) have taken many of us even further away from our genetic needs. While vegetarianism has a deep history dating back to about 500 BC, our paleolithic genes go back much further. Fossils of butchered animals with stone tool cut marks on their bones have been discovered in Africa dating back 2.5 million years. Every hominid skeleton examined since the emergence of homo sapiens shows signature characteristics of meat-based diets.

Renowned Paleo researcher Loren Cordain recently analyzed 229 hunter-gatherer diets and showed beyond question that no historically studied foragers were vegetarians. When animal foods were available, they were always preferred over plant foods. Of the hunter-gatherer groups, 73% consumed 46% or more of their daily calories from animal food.

Recent research has found no benefit to disease and all-cause mortality with vegetarian/vegan versus meat eaters. There are also numerous nutrient deficiencies that make vegetarian/vegan diets much more difficult to justify.
  • Vitamin B-12 deficiency leads to numerous maladies, as well as high homocysteine levels, which has been linked to CVD, neurological conditions, infertility, and bone disorders.
  • Menstrual problems/irregularities are common.
  • Zinc deficiency can impair sperm and immune function.
  • Mineral deficiencies are vast because diets high in phytate (in many foods that dominate vegetarian/vegan diets) impair the bodies ability to draw nutrients from those foods. Calcium, iron, and iodine are particularly affected.
  • Vitamin D deficiency is common because whole grains negatively affects serum D status.
  • Vitamin B-6 is difficult to absorb from plant materials and much better absorbed through animal flesh.
  • Omega-3 fatty acid deficiency is common because without grass-feed beef consumption, or more importantly, fatty fish, breaking down vegetable oils into usable EPA and DHA is virtually impossible to meet daily need. Plant foods contain no EPA and DHA. They contain ALA, which has to be enzymatically converted into EPA and DHA. Humans are poor converters. Vegans obtain no EPA and DHA whatsoever.
  • Taurine deficiency is common because this amino acid, while plentiful in animal foods, is not so in plants.
A fascinating debate was published in Journal of Nutrition and Athletic Excellence between the authors of The Paleo Diet and The China Study. You can read the debate its entirety at http://www.cathletics.com. Just type in The Protein Debate in the search box.

In our opinion, the debate wasn't even close. Dr. Cordain recorded an early knockout.
Simply, Dr. Cordain's evidence examines the ancient environment under which our genome arose to gain insight into our present day nutritional requirements (2.6 million years ago to right before agricultural began). This is not theory. It is based upon scientific data.

Dr. Campbell's evidence, however, is based upon hypothesis and philosophy, which is why he did not cite a single reference. There is no existing fossil, archeological, anthropological, anatomical, ethnographic, or biochemical evidence to show that members of our genus routinely consumed low protein diets. In fact, without sufficient protein, our large energetically active brains would not have evolved.

No comments:

Post a Comment