Friday, February 3, 2012

Deciphering Evolution and Eating Part Four: Healthy Foods Can Be Unheathy.

Our hunter-gathering ancestors were in touch with how they felt from food. They did not care about taste, unless it told them that what they were eating was poison. They ate what made them feel good and gave them the most energy per calorie. Hence, the mantra "eat to live, not live to eat."

Most see food as a passion and way of life, where taste is king and queen. We often forget about how food makes us feel because of this. Many of you have become more in touch with the foods that make you feel good and bad. This is a tremendous gift. As you know, even food that we consider healthy may be good for one person, but poison for the next.

In part three,
we touched upon the fact that grains, and pseudo-grains to a lesser degree, contain high amounts of antinutrients. These are substances in plants that exist solely to ward off predators. Another group of commonly consumed foods that contain varying degrees of antinutrients are legumes. Along with softening, there is another reason why we are told to cook beans so thoroughly: to limit their antinutrient content. While cooking reduces some of the antinutrient content, it does not remove all of it. In some individuals, excessive antinutrient content can lead to leaky gut and intestinal inflammation.

Legumes with HIGH to MEDIUM antinutrient content:
Soy protein isolate
Textured vegetable protein
Navy beans
Soybeans
Soybean flour
Kidney beans
Fava Beans

Legumes with LOWER antinutrient content
Garbanzo beans
Green peas
Soy tempeh (fermented)
Bean shoot
Lentils
Canned baked beans
Lima beans
Green beans
Tofu
Mung beans
Soy milk
Peanuts

Why do many of us get gassy when we eat legumes?
They contain large amounts of complex sugars called oligosaccharides. We have the same problem our hunter-gatherer brethren had: we lack the digestive enzymes to break these down into simpler sugars.

Legume the Irritant?
Legumes also may be problematic because they contain protease inhibitors. Protease is a digestive enzyme that breaks down all proteins. When protease encounters a legume and tries to break down its protein, often times it cannot. This is why legume protein is only about 40 to 60% absorbed (if your digestive system is ideal). The other problem is that the pancreas then has to work overtime to secrete enzymes to break the legume down, which can create inflammation. For vegetarians and vegans who eat a lot beans, this can be problematic.

Lastly, legumes also contains the antinutrient pyhtate, which can limit mineral absorption.

Now, let's be clear. There are many substances in legumes that are beneficial and can be disease fighting. This foodstuff should not be eliminated from your diet unless a known intolerance or allergy exists. What we are saying is that modern humans have problems with legumes because overall, we have not evolved enough yet to tolerate a constant barrage of antinutrients. Our hunter-gatherer ancestors were exposed to antinutrients much less frequently. Consuming legumes in moderation and focusing on the ones with low antinutrients should suffice.

Gulp...We Cringe As We Write This.
Unfortunately, our genetics do not allow us the ability to tolerate white potato very well. One of the most common intolerances we see in our screenings is white potato. Besides containing antinutrient content similar to legumes, white potato also creates blood sugar ebbs and flows, especially if consumed without a protein or healthy fat. Its glycemic index and load is actually higher than even some sugars. The fact that Americans eat too many white potatoes exacerbates the problem.

White potato is also very common in products for celiac and gluten intolerants, so this is why you should make sure you are not intolerant to potatoes or have blood sugar issues. If intolerant, then you should choose other roots and tubers (see below).

Roots and Tubers With High Glycemic Index/Load
Cassava (manioc and tapioca)
White Potato

Roots and Tubers With Medium to Low Index/Load
Taro
Parsnip
Sweet Potato
Yam
Beets
Rutabagas
Carrots
Jerusalem Artichoke
Chicory
Celeriac
Turnip

From a blood sugar perspective, if you consume copious amounts of cassava and white potato, eliminate at least one serving per day and replace with lower glycemic/load fare or non-root vegetable. The idea is to ultimately phase in as many low glycemic/load roots and tubers and consume cassava and white potato in moderation.
If blood sugar is an issue, never eat white potato or cassava by themselves. Consume with a protein and/or healthy fat.

You may be feeling like there is nothing left out there to eat. Don't look at it that way. Simply, we are elucidating the lack of advances in human evolution and why we are unable to tolerate foods we so commonly consume. We always aim to optimize your eating habits. If you can replace one serving of white potato with a rutabaga, we consider this a positive for your well-being.

A simple rule of thumb is the 75% to 25% rule of optimum to occasional eating (of course, avoid what you know you don't tolerate, even if it is considered an optimum food).

No comments:

Post a Comment