Friday, September 2, 2011

Hi Protein, Low Glycemic Rules

A September study from Evidence Based Medicine followed 1209 overweight and obese adults (body mass index between 27 and 45) from eight European countries. Eligible participants were aged between 18 and 65 and had at least one healthy child. They were invited to take part in an 8-week low-calorie diet, and those who achieved at least an 8% weight loss were eligible to participate in a 6-month weight-loss maintenance trial. Of the 938 who took part in the diet, 773 were then randomized to one of four dietary maintenance interventions: a high protein (25% of energy) or a low protein (13% of energy), with either a high-GI (glycemic index) diet or low-GI diet (15 GI units lower than high GI); alternatively, they were randomized to a control diet with an average protein level. Fat content was 25–30% of energy. The outcomes reported in this article were weight, fat and lean mass, waist and hip circumference and 24 h urinary urea and plasma urea.

This remarkably successful study has shown that a family-focused intervention can achieve an 11 kg weight loss and maintain nearly all of it for 6 months. This study has confirmed previous shorter and smaller studies that show that increasing protein and lowering GI increases weight loss or weight maintenance by about 0.6–1 kg for each intervention and that the two changes are entirely additive. This study has also shown that advising people to increase their protein intake is relatively ineffective in achieving an increase in protein and enhancing weight maintenance, whereas providing high-protein foods is effective as has been previously shown. The reverse was shown with GI: providing low-GI foods was ineffective relative to high-GI foods, while asking people to choose low-GI foods enhanced dietary compliance. This finding suggests the GI of foods per se has no impact on weight maintenance which differs from the authors' conclusions. In their discussion, the authors confuse GI and glycemic load (GL). There is better evidence that lowering GL by lowering carbohydrate, increasing protein and lowering GI has more of an effect on weight than lowering GI without changing the carbohydrate amount.

No comments:

Post a Comment