Thursday, April 14, 2011

Our Take: Alternative Headache Treaments Delight

Bonnie and Steve: a recently published study from journal Headache: Alternative Headache Treatments, Nutraceuticals, Behavioral and Physical Treatments is as exciting a piece on headaches as we have seen.

"According to researchers, there is a growing body of evidence supporting the efficacy of various complementary and alternative medicine approaches in the management of headache disorders. These treatment modalities include nutraceuticals, physical and behavioral therapies." Bonnie and Steve: we have summarized this review and commented on what we feel are the most important parts for our clients and readers.

CAM

The use of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) has increased in patients with neurological disorders, and now appears to be in widespread use among patients even in tertiary headache care. In a recent questionnaire-based survey conducted in Germany and Austria, the majority (81.7%) of patients attending tertiary outpatient headache clinics reported use of CAM. CAM usage is often motivated by dissatisfaction with conventional therapies and medication side effects, or a desire to be proactive against a disabling disorder.

Research
Data from the National Library of Medicine (PubMed), The Cochrane Library, and the American Academy of Neurology's Evidence-Based Guidelines were searched through August 2010 to identify studies, reviews, case series, reports or other information that assessed the alternative treatment of headache or migraine.

Nutraceuticals
The evidence for some nutraceuticals is promising, especially for magnesium.

Magnesium
Essential cation that plays a vital role in multiple physiological processes, may have several roles in migraine pathogenesis. Deficiency in magnesium has been associated with cortical spreading depression, neurotransmitter release, platelet aggregation, and vasoconstriction, all of which are important aspects of our current understanding of migraine pathophysiology. In addition, magnesium concentration influences serotonin receptors, nitric oxide synthesis and release, inflammatory mediators, and various other migraine-related receptors and neurotransmitters. Magnesium also plays a role in the control of vascular tone and reactivity to endogenous hormones and neurotransmitters, through its relationship with the NMDA receptor. Deficiency in magnesium results in the generation and release of substance P, which subsequently acts on sensory fibers, resulting in headache pain.

Given its commercial availability, the red blood cell (RBC) magnesium assay is a good way of assessing for deficiency, as improvements in clinical symptoms correlating with corrected levels would clearly demonstrate the benefits of magnesium supplementation.

Several studies have shown that magnesium supplementation is effective in migraine treatment. In one study, women with menstrual migraine receiving 360 mg of magnesium daily from ovulation to the first day of flow resulted in a significant reduction of the number of days with headache, total pain index, as well as an improvement of the Menstrual Distress Questionnaire score compared to placebo. Two other study comprising migraineurs also showed that attack frequency was reduced by 41.6% in the magnesium group.

The most common adverse effect associated with oral magnesium supplementation is diarrhea. Bonnie and Steve - this is why the glycinate form is so wonderful. It does not cause loose stool.

Several studies have also shown positive results with Intravenous Magnesium treatment. 1 g of magnesium sulfate resulted in rapid headache relief in patients with low serum levels. In another trial of patients with moderate to severe migraine attacks, treatment with 1 g intravenous magnesium sulfate was superior to placebo in terms of both response rate (100% for magnesium sulfate vs 7% for placebo) and pain-free rate (87% for magnesium sulfate and 0% for placebo). Of note, none of the subjects reported headache recurrence during the 24 hours after treatment.

Bonnie and Steve: so...now are you convinced with regards to magnesium?!

Supplements and Mitochondrial Dysfunction
Mitochondrial dysfunction, which leads to impaired oxygen metabolism, has been speculated to play a role in migraine pathophysiology as migraineurs have been shown to have reduced mitochondrial phosphorylation potential in between headaches. An impairment of mitochondrial oxidative metabolism might influence neuronal information processing, therefore reducing the threshold for migraine attacks. This is the rationale for the use of supplements that enhance mitochondrial function in the treatment of migraine, such as riboflavin, CoQ10, and alpha lipoic acid.

Riboflavin
Also known as vitamin B2, is a component of 2 coenzymes (flavin adenine dinucleotide and flavin mononucleotide). One well-designed study found that it is beneficial in migraine prophylaxis, showing that daily use of 400 mg riboflavin for 3 months resulted in a 50% reduction in attacks in 59% of patients, compared to 15% for placebo. A recent pharmacogenetic study demonstrated that riboflavin may be more effective in the treatment of migraine patients with non-H mitochondrial DNA haplotypes. These results may have ethnic implications, in that haplogroup H is predominantly found in the European population.

Coenzyme Q10 (CoQ10)
An endogenous enzyme cofactor involved in the mitochondrial electron transport chain, generating energy through its role in aerobic cellular respiration. Two small studies thus far have shown some benefit of CoQ10 in migraine treatment. In the first, migraineurs who used 150 mg daily of CoQ10 for 3 months, 61% had at least a 50% reduction in migraine days. Notably, supplementation was effective within the first month of treatment. The second study found that CoQ10 significantly decreased attack frequency, headache days, and days with nausea. Coenzyme Q10 supplementation may be especially effective in the prophylaxis of pediatric migraine. CoQ10 levels were measured in a study of 1550 pediatric patients with frequent headaches. Patients with low CoQ10 received supplementation with 1 to 3 mg/kg per day of CoQ10 in liquid gel capsule formulation, resulting in an improvement in total CoQ10 levels, headache frequency and degree of headache disability. Bonnie and Steve: chalk up yet another benefit for this wonderful substance.

Alpha Lipoic Acid
Also known as thioctic acid, it is a naturally occurring fatty acid that augments mitochondrial oxygen metabolism and adenosine triphosphate production. In one study, subjects received either 600 mg alpha lipoic acid or placebo daily for 3 months. There was a trend toward reduction of migraine frequency after treatment with alpha lipoic acid, as well as a significant reduction in attack frequency, headache days, and headache severity in the treatment group. Bonnie and Steve: as we have said many times before, ALA is the most broad-spectrum antioxidant there is.

Butterbur (Petasites Hybridus)
A perennial shrub found throughout Europe and parts of Asia. It was used for many centuries as a remedy for pain, fever, spasms, and wound healing. Petasites likely acts through calcium channel regulation and inhibition of peptide leukotriene biosynthesis, thus influencing the inflammatory cascade associated with migraine. One study in patients taking 50 mg of Petadolex® twice daily showed a significantly reduced number of migraine attacks and migraine days per month compared to placebo. Another study found that Petasites extract 75 mg twice daily was more effective than placebo in decreasing the number of monthly migraine attacks. Maximum response was achieved after 3 months, resulting in an attack reduction of 58% with the higher dose of Petadolex®, compared to the placebo response of 28%. Butterbur should not be used by pregnant women. Bonnie and Steve: it can also be good for allergies. For some, butterbur is great. For others, however, we have seen some very strong adverse reactions.

Feverfew
Herbal preparation that was used for centuries in the treatment of fevers, headache, infertility, toothaches, inflammation and arthritis. Feverfew may act in migraine prophylaxis by inhibiting platelet aggregation as well as the release of serotonin from platelets and white blood cells. It may also act as an anti-inflammatory agent through the inhibition of prostaglandin synthesis and phospholipse A. The efficacy of feverfew in migraine prophylaxis has been controversial, as many trials conducted in the past 3 decades have yielded contradictory results. Feverfew should not be used by pregnant women, as it may cause uterine contractions resulting in miscarriage or preterm labor. It can also cause allergic reactions; patients with allergies to other members of the daisy family, including ragweed and chrysanthemums, are more likely to be allergic to feverfew.

Behavioral and Physical Therapies
According to the US Headache Consortium, behavioral and physical treatments may be particularly beneficial in patients with one or more of the following characteristics: patient preference for non-pharmacological interventions; poor tolerance for specific pharmacological treatments; medical contraindications for specific pharmacological treatments; insufficient or no response to pharmacological treatment; pregnancy, planned pregnancy, or nursing; history of long-term, frequent, or excessive use of analgesic or acute medications that can aggravate headache problems (or lead to decreased responsiveness to other pharmacotherapies); significant stress or deficient stress-coping skills.

Behavioral Treatments
Relaxation training, thermal BFB combined with relaxation training, electromyography (EMG) biofeedback (BFB), and cognitive behavioral therapy can be considered as treatment options for prevention of migraine, based on Grade A evidence. The 2010 European Federation of Neurological Societies guidelines states that non-pharmacological modalities should always be considered. Behavioral treatment may be administered in clinic-based, limited-contact, and home-based formats, and patients may be seen individually or as part of a group. Limited-contact treatment usually involves 3 or 4 monthly treatment sessions during which skills are introduced. Audiotapes and manuals are subsequently used at home for practicing and refining skills, with clinicians assisting occasionally via telephone. Furthermore, the cost-effectiveness of home-based treatments has been found to be more than 5 times that of clinic-based therapies.

Biofeedback
A common intervention utilized in the treatment of pain disorders. It involves the monitoring and voluntary control of physiologic processes, allowing patients to take an active role in managing their pain. This in turn results in improved coping with the psychological and psychosocial consequences of their condition. In small trials, BFB demonstrated superior clinical results when compared to waiting list control and was shown to be at least equally effective in comparison to psychological placebo controls, relaxation, and pharmacotherapy. Also noted were reductions in the associated symptoms of depression and anxiety, and an increase in patients' sense of self-efficacy. Additional home training enhanced the direct and the follow-up treatment effect sizes, and was an important predictor of long-term outcome. Not only did BFB result in symptom reduction of over half a standard deviation, the treatment effects remained stable over a follow-up period of more than 1 year, on average. Furthermore, these effects appeared to be amplified over the long term. The efficacy recommendation given was Level 5, the highest level of evidence according to the AAPB/ISNR criteria, granted in cases where Level 4 evidence has been established and additional superior treatment results in comparison to credible sham therapy or alternative bona fide treatments have been shown. Bonnie and Steve: we have found that effectiveness with this therapy all depends upon the practitioner.

Relaxation Training
Can be considered a core component of behavioral treatment, as it can be used either alone or in conjunction with other behavioral modalities. Relaxation techniques are used to decrease sympathetic arousal and physiologic responses to stress by enhancing the awareness of tense and relaxed muscles.

Progressive relaxation training is the classic form and is still widely used. It promotes the recognition of tension and relaxation in the course of daily life. Patients are taught to sequentially tense and relax various muscle groups while taking note of the opposing sensations. Patients can typically learn progressive relaxation training in less than 10 sessions. While techniques are usually learned in a dark, quiet setting, they can be subsequently applied to everyday situations.

Autogenic training is another popular form of relaxation training. Autosuggestion, the process by which one induces self-acceptance of an opinion, belief, or plan of action, plays a central role in the process. In autogenic training, mental and somatic functions are concurrently regulated by passive concentration on formulas such as "my forehead is cool."

Various other traditional relaxation techniques include visual or guided imagery, cue-controlled relaxation, diaphragmatic breathing, and hypnosis. With regular practice, patients often find that relaxation techniques become automatic and are carried out without conscious effort.

Cognitive Behavioral
A form of psychotherapeutic treatment that addresses the relationships between stress, coping, and headache using cognitive and behavioral strategies. While cognitive strategies focus on identifying and challenging dysfunctional thoughts and the beliefs that give rise to these thoughts, behavioral strategies aim to help identify behaviors that may trigger, increase or perpetuate headaches. CBT is usually most beneficial in patients with concurrent significant psychological or environment problems that exacerbate headaches or prevent the implementation of self-regulation skills, such as chronic work stress, mood disorders, or adjustment problems. As such, it is also used to address and manage headache co-morbidities such as depression, anxiety, panic attacks, eating disorders, and sleep disorders. The US Headache Consortium found that CBT in the preventative treatment of migraine was supported by Grade A evidence. Combining it with relaxation training and BFB may increase treatment efficacy, especially in patients with psychiatric co-morbidities, high levels of stress, or poor coping.

Physical Treatments
The US Headache Consortium found that evidenced-based treatment recommendations were not yet possible regarding the use of acupuncture, TENS, cervical manipulation, or occlusal adjustment as preventive or acute therapy for migraine. More recently, a structured review on physical treatments for headache was undertaken, and found only modest support for the use of physical treatments in selected circumstances. Positive recommendations could be made in only a few clinical scenarios.

For migraine, recommendations were made for physical therapy combined with aerobic exercise, as well as physical therapy combined with relaxation therapy and thermal BFB.

For tension-type headache (TTH), there was a trend toward benefit from chiropractic manipulation, although the evidence was weak. Physical therapy was recommended, especially in high-frequency TTH cases.

Cervical spinal manipulative therapy was found to be as effective as amitriptyline (medication) in short-term use for chronic tension-type headache, and more effective than massage for cervicogenic headache. Other recent studies have reported that physical therapy can be effective in reducing headache frequency, intensity and duration in CTTH patients. Overall, these physical treatments are most beneficial when integrated into a multimodal treatment plan including exercise, stretching, and ergonomics training for both the home and the workplace. Patients who express an interest in physical treatments are more likely to benefit from active strategies such as exercise than passive ones such as massage and heat or cold application.

Although cervical spinal manipulative therapy may provide benefit in some clinical cases as described above, it has been associated with a 6-fold increase in the risk of vertebral artery dissection and stroke or transient ischemic attack. As such, one should be cautious when considering a recommendation for this treatment, and patients who express interest in chiropractic maneuvers should be warned of this potential complication. Bonnie and Steve: we have worked with Chiropractor Dr. Liselotte Schuster for over twenty years and have never seen anything close to this adverse outcome.

Acupuncture
While the mechanism by which acupuncture provides an analgesic effect in migraine treatment is not fully understood, several theories have been hypothesized. Acupuncture has been shown to activate nervous system structures in the control of pain perception, which include the prefrontal cortex, the rostral anterior cingulated cortex and the brainstem, as demonstrated by studies where acupuncture-induced analgesia was inhibited by the experimental blockade of the pituitary gland, the arcuate nucleus of the hypothalamus, and the periaqueductal gray. Given that sham acupuncture provides a therapeutic effect in some patients, unknown factors independent of acupuncture methodology must exist that provide a reduction in migraine symptoms.

A 2001 Cochrane review of 16 randomized studies on acupuncture in the treatment of idiopathic headache, the authors concluded that evidence in support of acupuncture for migraine prophylaxis was considered promising but insufficient. Furthermore, there is no evidence that "true" acupuncture is more effective than sham interventions.

The review on acupuncture in the treatment of TTH showed that adding acupuncture to routine care or to acute treatment only reduces the short-term (3 months) frequency and intensity of headaches. Longer-term effects were not investigated. Six trials compared acupuncture with various sham interventions and collectively showed a small but significant reduction of headache frequency for true acupuncture as compared to sham procedures, over a 6-month period of time.

Acupuncture is a viable treatment alternative for migraine patients, especially those with contraindications to traditional pharmacological therapy or those with headaches that remain refractory to multiple trials of medications. Although the evidence supporting its use in TTH is not as strong, acupuncture could be beneficial in those patients with frequent episodic or chronic forms of the disorder. Several studies have also demonstrated that it is cost-effective in the treatment of headache.

Oxygen and Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy
Has been widely observed to be effective in the treatment of cluster headache, and is considered to be one of the standard acute treatments for the disorder. The use of oxygen therapy is advantageous in that it can be combined with other acute therapies, and used several times daily. It is also cheap, safe, and easy to use.

HBOT might be beneficial in the treatment of vascular-related headaches refractory to traditional pharmacological therapy. HBOT may be effective via its effect on several aspects of migraine pathogenesis, via activity as a serotonergic agonist and an immunomodulator of response to substance P. In addition, the role of HBOT in moderating inflammatory pathways may be useful in targeting migraine, both as acute and preventative treatment.

Practical limitations of HBOT include the requirement of a compression chamber and potential adverse effects such as pressure-related damage to the ears, sinuses, and lungs, temporary worsening of myopia, claustrophobia and oxygen poisoning.

There is insufficient evidence from randomized trials to establish whether HBOT is effective in the acute treatment of cluster headache. Lastly, there was no evidence to suggest that either NBOT or HBOT were effective in the prevention of either migraine or cluster headaches.

Conclusion
"There is a growing role for CAM treatment in the multidisciplinary management of headache disorders. In addition to their potential in decreasing headache frequency and intensity, these modalities also serve to provide the patient with a greater sense of self-efficacy. There is still much to be learned about these therapeutic options and how they influence the course and outcome of headache disorders. Future research should focus on extending the current evidence base using updated standards and more rigorous methodology, and identifying which patients would be responsive to such approaches." Bonnie and Steve: it is unusual for researchers to be this positive about so many different non-pharmacological headache modalities. For those suffering with headaches, you now have myriad options at your disposal. If there is one disappointment in the study, it would have to be that they did not consider studying the removal of dietary triggers.

No comments:

Post a Comment