Friday, February 25, 2011

Being Informed and Proactive in Today's Health Care - Part Two

Cancer Screenings
You know what they say: "the more you look, the more you'll find." There are millions of Americans each year who start prescriptions and take extra tests because of medical tests and screenings.

Just last week, the CDC released its annual Health United States Statistics. Cancer is the leading cause of death for persons ages 45-64 and second leading cause of death for 35-44 year olds. These have increased from a decade ago. With the increase in cancer screening, these numbers should have been reduced, if not drastically.

Mammograms
Three-quarters of women get them, yet breast cancer cases have declined mainly due to synthetic hormone-cessation. Some experts believe that targeted radiation to the breast produces a ten percent increase increase of cancer after just ten years. Not to mention that the pushing, prodding, and squeezing during a mammogram may make a potential tumor more likely to spread.
For cancer survivors, mammography is also less accurate at spotting breast cancer, according to a government-funded study that appeared in JAMA last week. As this is a personal decision, thermography, monthly breast examinations, and yearly clinical breast exams can be an alternative.

PSA
The creator of the PSA has distanced himself from this much maligned test. Over the last two decades, it is believed to have created countless unnecessary prescriptions, screenings, procedures, and surgeries. Numerous studies have considered the PSA an utter failure as a preventive screening device. Just last week, one of the largest studies ever performed showed that a rising PSA is a poor indicator for prostate cancer
and can lead to many unnecessary biopsies. Sloan-Kettering researchers stated that some men have cancer despite a "normal" PSA count of 4 or below.

CT Scans
They expose you to levels of radiation 10 times higher that what you would get with conventional X-rays. Ultrasound or MRI are safer modalities.

Human Error
I'm sure we have all heard a story about someone who received either a false positive or negative test. While false negatives do happen, especially with fast-growing cancers in their early stages, false positives, in which you are told of something suspicious that turns out to be nothing, are much more common. False positives lead to confirmatory testing such as ultrasound, CT scan, colonoscopy, and biopsy. Approximately ten percent of mammograms and up to three-quarters of PSAs are considered false positives. You have to remember that a human being (in this case a radiologist) is creating an opinion based upon what they see. In many cases, what one radiologist sees is totaly different from another radiologist. If you choose to get the following tests, here's what you can control to avoid false positives:
  • For any screening with suspicious results, get a second opinion!
  • Mammogram: do not apply deodorant or powders near your breast as tiny pieces may show up as suspicious lumps.
  • Pap Test: do not take the test until you have reached 12 to 14 days after your period to avoid the effects of hormones on the cervix.
  • PSA: if you give them any validity, know that levels rise as you age. Drugs to treat an enlarged prostate or blood pressure affect PSA levels.
  • Fecal Occult Blood Test: eat a high fiber diet 72 hours prior. Avoid red meat, aspirin, and large amounts of vitamin C as small amounts can appear in the stool. Any kind of bleeding, such as bleeding gums or a cut on the inside of your cheek can create a false positive.
Every human being has cancer cells in their body. Many cancers are so slow-growing that other causes of death occur before cancer does. That is, until a screening picks it up.

Cancer screenings are a very personal choice. Just make sure there is a good reason for the test: not for malpractice, financial incentives, or unwarranted fear.

No comments:

Post a Comment